BLOG

Article: Militant Courts and Private Power: Can Judicial Resistance to Big Tech Become Democratic Backsliding? The Brazilian Supreme Court and X (2024–2025)

16 NOVEMBER, 2026

1 MIN READ

Article: Militant Courts and Private Power: Can Judicial Resistance to Big Tech Become Democratic Backsliding? The Brazilian Supreme Court and X (2024–2025)

Author: Mr. Leandro Vusberg Coelho, Master's candidate in Constitutional Law at the Brazilian Institute of Education, Development and Research (IDP)

Abstract
In August 2024, a single justice of the Brazilian Supreme Court suspended X nationwide and fined citizens who circumvented the block; in 2025, the Court rewrote platform liability while Congress stood still. This brief asks whether such judicial resistance to a global platform can itself become democratic backsliding. Applying three markers — indivisibility of means, irreversibility towards non-parties, substitution of the legislator — it finds that the Brazilian path meets all three, whereas the EU Digital Services Act kept functions divided at the price of speed. It closes with recommendations for courts, national legislators and the European Commission

Read the full article below. 

This article was written as part of the EGPL Young Fellows Program 2026, an initiative of the European Public Law Organization (EPLO) linked to the Annual Reunion of the European Group of Public Law (EGPL), held from 11 to 13 September 2026 at the EPLO campus in Legrena–Cape Sounion, Greece. Selected early-career researchers in law and governance took part in the Reunion. Each then produced an original paper on this year’s theme, “New Challenges for the State”, with guidance from mentors in the ELGU academic network. The Fellows’ papers are published as a series on the ELG Blog.

Militant Courts and Private Power: Can Judicial Resistance to Big Tech Become Democratic Backsliding? The Brazilian Supreme Court and X (2024–2025)

AN AGENCY OF THE EUROPEAN PUBLIC LAW ORGANIZATION

A University backed by an international organization.

The ELGU is a university founded and operated by an international organization. Learn from practitioners, scholars, and experts who shape public life.

14 Member States
81 Universities

Permanent Observer at the UN General Assembly