Author: Mr. Theodor Skarvelis, Research Coordinator at the Institute of International Economic Relations (IIER) in Athens Greece.
Abstract
As Arctic sea ice retreats and the Northern Sea Route (NSR) attracts commercial and strategic attention, the divergent readings of the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea advanced by Russia and the United States have turned into a dispute over navigational rights. This paper reconstructs both positions and asks whether a Freedom of Navigation Operation (FONOP) is a realistic American response. It first examines Russia’s regulatory regime under Article 234 and the characterisation of the route’s straits as internal waters. It then sets out Washington’s counterclaims. The paper argues that a FONOP mission fits only part of this dispute, since an operational assertion can contest only restrictions applying to state vessels; its only plausible target is the internal-waters claim over the NSR’s straits, where ice conditions, the absence of ice-capable American warships and potential dependence on Russian assistance make the operation disproportionately risky. It concludes that diplomatic instruments, a published legal position, a renewed protest, joint démarches and pressure to submit the NSR rules to the IMO, offer a lower-risk way of preserving the American legal position.
Read the full article below
This article was written as part of the EGPL Young Fellows Program 2026, an initiative of the European Public Law Organization (EPLO) linked to the Annual Reunion of the European Group of Public Law (EGPL), held from 11 to 13 September 2026 at the EPLO campus in Legrena–Cape Sounion, Greece. Selected early-career researchers in law and governance took part in the Reunion. Each then produced an original paper on this year’s theme, “New Challenges for the State”, with guidance from mentors in the ELGU academic network. The Fellows’ papers are published as a series on the ELG Blog.